Punishment: The Downside

Punishment: The Downside

Think of the fun-loving Golden Retriever who suddenly grows anxious when it spots a skateboard, unpredictably darting away, causing concern for both the dog and the owner. Frustrated, the owner may resort to punishments like harsh commands or leash tugging. Yet, this article sheds light on the ineffectiveness of punishment as a correction method. We explore better alternatives – a combination of positive reinforcement and herbal supplements to reshape unwanted behaviours in dogs.

  • Fear and Stress: Dogs usually display unwanted behaviours due to fear. It is crucial to identify these stressors and manage them accordingly, instead of resorting to punishment.
  • Punishments: Physical or verbal punishments often lead to anxiety and fear in dogs, damaging the bond between the dog and the owner.
  • Alternative Approach: Combining positive reinforcement and herbal supplements have proved to be a more effective course in altering undesired canine behaviours.

Understanding Canine Behavior

Delving into the psychology of canines, encounters like the Golden Retriever’s stem from fear or discomfort. Dogs perceive their world through a prism of instincts – reacting to stimuli instantly, often without consciousness. Understanding these triggers can build a closer, more positive bond with your pet. A calm German Shepherd during thunderstorms didn’t achieve that state of panic-free peace overnight, it’s the result of understanding its fear and gently guiding it towards a healthier reaction.

  • Canine Psychology: Before training a dog, understanding what triggers certain behaviours is vital. Often, these behaviours stem from instinctual responses to fear or discomfort.
  • Dog's World Perception: Dogs react instantly to their environments, often without conscious thought, based on instincts. Recognizing these reactions can strengthen your bond with your dog.
  • Understanding Fear & Patience: By understanding your dog's fears, and guiding them patiently, you can help them achieve a state of calm and comfort.

Why Punishment Doesn't Work for Long-term Behavioural Change

In the realm of dog training, we often confuse suppressive reactions with learning. Punishments may bring immediate obedience but fail to teach alternative behaviour, resulting in fear, mistrust, or even aggression. Experts like Steve Lindsay, author of Handbook of Applied Dog Behaviour and Training, echoes this sentiment, advocating for more humane methods.

  • Suppression vs Learning: Immediate obedience through punishment often suppresses the dog's behaviour instead of teaching them new behaviours or alternative outcomes.
  • Punishment Outcomes: Punishment can potentially lead to fear, mistrust, and aggression. It's important to differentiate between obedience achieved through punitive means and obedience achieved through positive reinforcement and understanding.
  • Expert Opinion: Renowned dog behaviour and training expert, Steve Lindsay, is a vocal advocate for more humane methods of training dogs.

Transitioning to Positive Reinforcement: A Better Alternative

A gentler methodology, Positive reinforcement rewards behaviour we want to encourage, aiming dogs towards a clearer, more positive path. Think of the once skateboard-anxious Golden Retriever, now calmly observing the rolling wheeled-board pass by, thanks to an understanding owner who praised calm reactions with treats and comforting words. This fosters a stronger bond between the owner and the pet, proving more beneficial and enduring than punitive tactics.

  • Positive Reinforcement: It's a more efficient and humane way of training dogs, focusing on rewarding and encouraging desired behaviors.
  • Outcome: Positive reinforcement leads to a clearer, more positive path of behaviour making dogs more obedient and fulfilled.
  • Strengthening Bonds: This method not only trains your dog effectively, but also fosters a better emotional connection between you and your furry friend.

Herbal Supplements: A New Age Solution to Boost Behaviour Modification

In addition to positive reinforcement, integrating herbal supplements can support behaviour modification. Chamomile, for instance, is known for its calming properties and can help a dog relax, minimize anxiety, and promote better focus during training sessions.

  • Supplementary Support: Herbal supplements, integrated along with positive reinforcement, make for an effective behaviour modification strategy.
  • Chamomile: This herb has calming properties and can help dogs relax, reducing anxiety and promoting better focus during training.


Training is a two-way street, and dogs learn most effectively when we approach them with understanding and positivity. Opt for time-tested methods like positive reinforcement and consider the benefits of herbal supplements for enhanced results. Remember, a well-trained dog is a milestone on the path of a strong, fulfilling bond between a human and their furry friend.

One way to seamlessly augment your training efforts is through our natural hissing training spray. This odourless, harmless spray makes a hissing noise to instantly grab your dog's attention when they're about to misbehave, redirecting their focus and reinforcing good behavior. At just £9.99, with free delivery, a money back guarantee, and a support team based in the UK ready to assist you, it's an investment worth making.

Learn more about Calm the eff down instant

Back to blog